Are extended warranties ever worth it anymore?

Alex Clark

11/22/2025

Are extended warranties ever worth it anymore? — Image Credit: prostooleh / Freepik

As consumers face increasing costs and complexities in purchasing products, the question of whether extended warranties are worth the investment has become more pressing. Understanding the pros and cons of these warranties can help consumers make informed decisions in today’s market.

Understanding Extended Warranties

Extended warranties are service contracts that provide additional coverage beyond the manufacturer’s warranty for a specific period. They can take various forms, including product-specific plans for electronics, appliances, and vehicles, or broader service contracts that cover multiple items. For instance, Best Buy offers Geek Squad Protection plans that cover electronics for an extended period, while car dealerships often provide extended service plans that cover mechanical failures after the standard warranty expires.

Retailers and manufacturers market these warranties through persuasive tactics, often emphasizing the potential costs of repairs and highlighting the peace of mind that comes with additional protection. They may showcase testimonials or statistics indicating high repair costs for specific products, such as the average repair cost for a washing machine being around $300. However, consumers should be aware of the emotional appeal used in these pitches, which can sometimes cloud judgment.

There are several misconceptions surrounding extended warranties that can pressure consumers into purchasing them. For example, many believe that extended warranties are mandatory for new electronics or that they are a surefire way to save money on future repairs. In reality, many products are highly reliable, and the likelihood of needing significant repairs may not justify the cost of the warranty.

Cost vs. Value: Breaking Down the Numbers

The cost of extended warranties can vary significantly depending on the product category. For electronics, warranties can range from $50 for smaller items like headphones to over $300 for larger appliances like refrigerators. Vehicle warranties can be even more costly, with prices often climbing into the thousands, depending on the make and model. For instance, an extended warranty for a 2020 Honda Accord can cost between $1,000 and $2,500, depending on the coverage period and options selected.

Statistics reveal that many consumers rarely utilize extended warranties. According to a 2021 Consumer Reports survey, only about 20% of respondents filed a claim on their extended warranty, and the average payout was often less than the warranty’s cost. This data suggests that many consumers may be better served by setting aside the money they would spend on a warranty for potential repairs, which is a strategy known as self-insurance. By doing this, they can build a repair fund that may exceed the payout of an extended warranty in the long run.

Image credit: Antoni Shkraba Studio via Pexels

Factors to Consider Before Purchasing

Before deciding to purchase an extended warranty, assessing the product’s reliability is crucial. For example, devices like the Apple iPhone typically have a good track record for durability, and many users find they rarely need repairs within the first few years. In contrast, products known for frequent repairs, such as certain models of washing machines, may justify the additional coverage. Understanding the history and reliability of the specific model you are considering can greatly influence your decision.

It’s also essential to thoroughly review the warranty coverage details. Many extended warranties come with exclusions or limitations that can lead to frustration later. For instance, some warranties may not cover accidental damage or certain wear-and-tear issues. Knowing what is included and excluded can help avoid disappointment if a claim needs to be filed. Additionally, considering your purchasing habits and personal risk tolerance plays a significant role. If you frequently upgrade your devices, investing in an extended warranty may not be necessary.

Alternatives to Extended Warranties

Manufacturer warranties often provide sufficient coverage for a reasonable period, typically one year for electronics and up to three years for appliances. For example, Samsung typically offers a one-year warranty on their televisions, which may cover defects and repairs. This initial coverage can often negate the need for an extended warranty, especially for products known for reliability.

Additionally, many credit cards offer purchase protection or extended warranty benefits when the card is used to buy products. For example, the Chase Sapphire Preferred card provides up to an extra year of warranty coverage on eligible items purchased with the card. Utilizing these benefits can be a cost-effective way to extend protection without the need for a separate warranty.

Another alternative is repair insurance, which can be more beneficial than traditional extended warranties in some cases. Repair insurance plans focus on covering specific types of failures or damages for a monthly fee rather than a one-time warranty purchase. For instance, companies like Lemonade offer renters insurance that can include coverage for personal property repairs, providing an avenue for protection that can be tailored to individual needs.