Federal prosecutors say a South Florida husband and wife turned a Davie luxury dealership into the hub of a sprawling title fraud operation that touched some of the most coveted performance cars on the market, including a Nissan GT-R and a Porsche 911. Investigators allege the couple quietly converted salvage and even stolen vehicles into seemingly clean inventory, then pushed them to buyers who had little reason to suspect anything was wrong until the paperwork unraveled.

The case, which centers on more than three dozen criminal counts and an alleged loss topping $500,000, offers a stark look at how sophisticated paperwork schemes can weaponize state rebuilt-title systems. It also shows how a single dealership, armed with forged invoices and falsified forms, can move high-end metal from the shadows of insurance auctions to the front line of a glossy showroom.

The couple behind the luxury lot

According to federal and local investigators, the operation was run by Michael Anthony Lucci, 32, and his wife, Emily Marie Lucci, 30, who owned a luxury car dealership in Davie. The pair are accused of orchestrating a pattern of mail fraud and title fraud that touched at least 48 vehicles and generated an alleged haul of about $500,000 in illicit proceeds. Authorities say the couple used their control of the dealership to blur the line between legitimate sales and a hidden pipeline of improperly titled cars.

Charging documents describe more than three dozen counts, including nine allegations that the couple submitted false information in official paperwork to secure rebuilt titles. Investigators say the Luccis relied on fraudulent invoices and fabricated repair records to persuade Florida officials that heavily damaged or otherwise ineligible vehicles had been properly restored and vetted. Once those titles were issued, the cars could be marketed as attractive, roadworthy examples rather than the risky salvage or stolen property they had been before.

How a title scam turns wrecks into “clean” exotics

The core of the alleged scheme was not the metal itself but the paper that followed it. Investigators say the Davie dealership repeatedly used bogus invoices and misleading documentation to obtain rebuilt titles from Florida for vehicles that should never have cleared that process. By presenting the state with what appeared to be legitimate repair histories and ownership chains, the couple allegedly transformed cars with serious baggage into inventory that could be advertised as fully rehabilitated and legally sound.

Once those titles were in hand, the dealership could list the vehicles at prices that reflected their apparent condition rather than their true histories. Authorities say the pattern extended across dozens of cars, with the couple allegedly using the mail to submit and receive key documents, a detail that underpins the federal mail fraud counts. The investigation later found that at least eight vehicles offered for sale carried rebuilt titles issued by Florida that were based on fraudulent paperwork, a figure that illustrates how systemic the alleged manipulation had become rather than a one-off paperwork error.

The GT-R, the 911 and a suspicious price jump

Among the vehicles that drew investigators’ attention were a Nissan GT-R and a Porsche 911, both halo cars that can command strong money when they appear to have clean histories. According to investigative summaries, one of the cars tied to the case was sold by the dealership in 2022 for $55,000, then later reappeared in the inventory at a dramatically higher asking price of $94,500. That swing, authorities say, coincided with efforts to secure a rebuilt title that would make the car more attractive to buyers and lenders, even as questions lingered about its past.

Investigators say the GT-R and 911 were part of a broader pattern in which the dealership acquired damaged or otherwise problematic performance cars, then sought to launder their histories through Florida’s rebuilt-title process. In at least one instance, an attempt to obtain a title reportedly triggered a notification that the vehicle had been reported stolen in North Carolina, a red flag that underscored how far some of the inventory was from the glossy image presented on the lot. The combination of eye-catching models and aggressive pricing, backed by paperwork that appeared official, made the scheme particularly difficult for ordinary buyers to detect until law enforcement stepped in.

The Hellcat that was “not even close” to legal

While the GT-R and 911 helped draw public attention, investigators point to another car as a vivid example of how extreme the alleged fraud became. The Hellcat, a high horsepower variant of Dodge’s muscle cars, was described by authorities as “not even close” to being legal. According to investigative reports, The Hellcat carried multiple vehicle identification numbers, a classic indicator that parts from different cars had been stitched together or that the car’s identity had been deliberately obscured.

Officials say the paperwork attached to The Hellcat did not match the physical reality of the car, yet the dealership still sought to move it through the rebuilt-title pipeline and into retail sale. The presence of multiple VINs, combined with the broader pattern of falsified invoices, suggested to investigators that the car was more than a simple restoration project gone wrong. Instead, it became a symbol of how the alleged scheme pushed far beyond gray areas and into territory where both safety and basic legal compliance were in question.

Miami-Dade investigators, federal charges and shaken buyers

The case began to unravel when Miami-Dade authorities focused on the Davie dealership’s paperwork, eventually arresting the owners after tracing a series of suspicious title applications. Investigators in Miami and Dade counties say the dealership’s use of fraudulent invoices to obtain rebuilt titles triggered a deeper review of its inventory, which in turn exposed the pattern of questionable vehicles, including those with ties to other states. That local work fed into a federal indictment that framed the couple’s conduct as a major mail fraud and title fraud operation rather than a handful of isolated mistakes.

For buyers, the fallout has been both financial and emotional. Some customers who thought they were driving away in carefully reconditioned performance cars instead found themselves entangled in investigations, facing the possibility that their vehicles could be seized or deemed unsafe. Reports describe at least one buyer who discovered that a car purchased from the dealership had a rebuilt title based on fraudulent documentation, a revelation that left the owner “very annoyed” and worried about both value and liability. As the case moves forward, it has become a cautionary tale for anyone shopping in Florida’s booming luxury used-car market, where a glossy finish and a stack of paperwork are no guarantee that a GT-R, a 911 or even The Hellcat is what it appears to be.

More from Fast Lane Only