A test drive that began like any other at a Texas dealership ended with a stolen Ford Mustang, a gun, and a trail of clues so clumsy that investigators barely had to break a sweat. The suspect, described by authorities as armed and erratic, allegedly sped away in a brand‑new 2025 Mustang and then made the kind of mistake that turns a serious crime into a cautionary tale: he left his own identification behind. What followed was a rapid manhunt across multiple counties, a federal case, and a vivid example of how modern car theft can look both dangerous and strangely inept at the same time.
The test drive that turned into a carjacking
Sales staff at Silsbee Ford treated the visit like any other potential sale, sending a representative out in a new 2025 Ford Mustang with a prospective buyer for a routine test drive. According to law enforcement accounts, the drive left the lot and headed toward the area near Silsbee Elementary, where the tone shifted from sales pitch to threat. Investigators say the customer, identified as Justin Keith Colley, allegedly produced a firearm during the drive, turning a standard dealership practice into a carjacking in a matter of moments and forcing the employee out of the vehicle before taking off alone in the Mustang.
Reports describe how the incident unfolded shortly after the car left the dealership, with Colley allegedly brandishing the weapon near Silsbee Elementary and ordering the salesman out of the Mustang on the roadside. The vehicle, a new model that had just been entrusted to a stranger for a test drive, was suddenly in the hands of an armed suspect who had no intention of returning it. The dealership, Silsbee Ford, was left with a missing car, a shaken employee, and a crime that would quickly draw in multiple agencies across Southeast Texas.
A “brilliant” mistake: leaving his own ID behind
What might have been a more complicated investigation became significantly simpler when detectives discovered that the suspect had allegedly left behind a crucial piece of evidence at Silsbee Ford. According to Police accounts, the man who drove off in the Mustang had provided his identification to the dealership as part of the standard test drive process, then failed to retrieve it before fleeing. That ID, which one report notes appeared to include a reference to “C.I.A.”, gave investigators a full name, photograph, and address even before the Mustang was spotted again on the road.
Officers did not have to start with grainy surveillance footage or vague witness descriptions. Instead, they had a driver’s license and dealership paperwork tying the test drive directly to Justin Keith Colley, identified in later charging documents as 37. The decision to leave his own identification behind, while allegedly committing an armed car theft, turned what could have been a drawn‑out search into a targeted pursuit. It is the kind of misstep that has prompted observers to describe the case as both alarming and oddly “brilliant” in its lack of foresight, even as the underlying conduct remains serious and violent.
The chase across county lines
Once the Mustang and its driver were gone, the search moved quickly beyond the dealership’s lot and into neighboring jurisdictions. Law enforcement bulletins went out describing the stolen 2025 Ford Mustang and the armed suspect, and agencies across the region began watching highways and rural routes for any sign of the car. The break came when Deputy Jacob Spivey with the Jasper County Sheriff Office spotted a Mustang matching the description during patrol on Highway, around midafternoon. The vehicle was reportedly displaying an outdated license plate that did not match the car, a detail that immediately raised suspicions for Officers already on alert.
Police accounts describe how the mismatched and outdated plate, combined with the earlier alert about the stolen Mustang, gave Deputy Jacob Spivey enough cause to move in. Once the vehicle was confirmed to be the same Mustang taken from Silsbee Ford, officers initiated a stop and took the driver into custody. The arrest near Buna, in Jasper County the, capped a search that had stretched from the dealership’s city streets to regional highways, and it underscored how quickly coordinated communication between agencies can close the gap on a fleeing suspect, even one armed and initially at large.
From local arrest to federal carjacking case
The consequences for the alleged thief did not stop at a local booking. After the arrest, investigators and prosecutors reviewed the circumstances of the test drive, the reported use of a firearm, and the interstate implications of a stolen vehicle taken at gunpoint. Those factors led to federal carjacking and firearms charges against the Silsbee man, elevating the case from a dealership theft to a serious federal prosecution. Charging documents describe how the use of a gun to seize the Mustang during the test drive, combined with the subsequent flight across county lines, met the threshold for federal involvement.
Later reports detail how the suspect, identified as Justin Keith Colley, faced a three‑count indictment that included carjacking and being in possession of a firearm. The Mustang, initially just a prized piece of inventory on the Silsbee Ford lot, became central evidence in a case that could carry a lengthy prison sentence. One account notes that the potential punishment for such a carjacking, involving a firearm and a stolen 2025 Ford Mustang, can reach between 15 and 99 years in jail, underscoring how a single test drive gone wrong can reshape a defendant’s entire future.
A bizarre explanation and a broader warning
As the legal process moved forward, the narrative around the suspect’s motives took an even stranger turn. In footage recorded after the arrest, the man accused of stealing the Mustang at gunpoint is heard offering an unusual justification for his actions. When asked why he took the car, he responds that he was trying to deliver classified intelligence to the CIA, and when pressed further, he links that claim to a belief that Amer needed his help. The explanation, disconnected from the straightforward facts of the theft, added a surreal layer to a case already marked by the contradiction of a dangerous crime and an almost self‑sabotaging mistake.
For dealerships and law enforcement alike, the episode functions as a pointed warning about the risks embedded in everyday business practices. Silsbee Ford followed a common routine by allowing a test drive after collecting identification, yet still found itself facing an armed carjacking in the middle of a weekday. At the same time, the swift resolution, aided by the suspect’s decision to leave his ID behind and the quick work of Police and Officers across multiple jurisdictions, shows how basic safeguards and coordinated response can limit the damage. The Mustang was recovered, the suspect was arrested, and a case that began with a “brilliant” blunder now stands as a stark example of how quickly a reckless decision can escalate into a life‑altering criminal prosecution.
More from Fast Lane Only
